Mafia roleplay is about crime families: loyalty, honour, power, betrayal and the cost of a life outside the law. This primer covers family structure, the codes characters live by, story ideas, and how to keep it more than gangster clichés.
Mafia stories usually draw on the Italian-American and Sicilian Mafia, but the same ideas fit any organised crime family: Irish mobs, the Russian bratva, the Japanese yakuza, or a family you invent for a fantasy city.
Family structure
A classic Mafia family, as it's usually described:
| Rank | Role |
|---|---|
| Boss (Don) | Runs the family. Makes the final decisions. |
| Underboss | Second in command, often the heir. |
| Consigliere | The advisor, often a lawyer or old friend, who tells the boss what he doesn't want to hear. |
| Caporegime (Capo) | A captain who runs a crew of soldiers. |
| Soldier | A full, "made" member of the family. |
| Associate | Works with the family but isn't a member. Drivers, informants, business partners. |
The codes
- Omertà: silence. Never talk to the police, never betray the family.
- Respect: rank and courtesy matter. An insult can start a war.
- Family first: blood family and crime family overlap, and conflict.
- Debts and favours: everything is owed, and everything gets collected.
The drama comes from characters who break the codes, or are torn between them.
Characters to play
- The heir who doesn't want the family business.
- The boss's spouse, who knows more than anyone thinks.
- An undercover cop deep inside the family.
- A doctor who stitches up gunshot wounds, no questions asked.
- A rival family's daughter in an arranged marriage meant to keep the peace.
- A loyal soldier ordered to kill a friend.
- An accountant who keeps the books, and copies.
Story ideas
- A war between families, and two people from opposite sides who fall for each other.
- The boss is dying, and the succession fight begins.
- Someone in the family is talking to the police.
- An outsider witnesses a crime and is pulled in.
- A shipment goes missing, and everyone suspects everyone.
See Trope Prompts for enemies to lovers and arranged marriage starters that fit this setting well.
Avoiding the clichés
- Not every character needs a gun. The lawyers, spouses, cooks and children make the world feel real.
- Violence should cost something. Funerals, revenge, guilt, police attention.
- Avoid ethnic caricature. Italian-American characters aren't all gangsters, and heavy fake accents or stereotypes are hurtful. See Writing Characters From Other Cultures.
- Glamour versus reality. Mafia romance is a popular genre, but the people involved are criminals. Decide how dark you and your partner want it, and rate it. See Content Ratings.
For writing the boss's menace, see Writing a Compelling Villain. For group threads with a whole family, see Group Roleplay.