1. Help
  2. Tutorials
  3. Inspiration and resources

Superhero Roleplay: Powers, Limits and Secret Identities

Superhero roleplay is about people with extraordinary powers and the ordinary lives, secret identities and moral choices that come with them. The best superhero stories are about character first and powers second.

Whether you're writing in a big comic universe or creating your own heroes and villains, this primer covers powers and limits, identities, story types and the pitfalls to avoid.

Powers and limits

The most important rule: every power needs a limit. Without one, there's no tension, and your partner has nothing to do.

PowerPossible limit or cost
Super strengthCan't control it when emotional; breaks things they love.
FlightExhausting; easy to spot; useless indoors.
TelepathyCan't switch it off; hears things they wish they hadn't.
HealingTakes on the injury, or the pain, themselves.
SpeedBurns calories fast; time feels painfully slow to them.
InvisibilityOnly when holding their breath; people forget they're there even when visible.
Elemental controlNeeds the element nearby; weather affects their mood.

Agree on power levels with your partner before any conflict. See Power Balance in RP.

Secret identities

  • Who knows? Family, partner, best friend, their enemy?
  • What does the secret cost? Missed birthdays, lies to loved ones, a double life that's falling apart.
  • What happens if it's revealed? That's a plot waiting to happen.

Character types

  • The classic hero: wants to do good and struggles with what that means.
  • The reluctant hero: didn't ask for powers, doesn't want them.
  • The anti-hero: gets results by methods heroes won't use.
  • The sidekick: in someone's shadow, ready to step out.
  • The villain: often a mirror of the hero. See Writing a Compelling Villain.
  • The civilian: no powers, a lot of courage; journalists, doctors, partners.
  • The retired hero: hung up the cape, and keeps getting pulled back.

RPL's Character roles include Protagonist/Hero, Anti-Hero, Sidekick and Antagonist/Villain; see Character Archetypes.

Story ideas

  • A hero and villain discover they're neighbours.
  • Powers are made illegal, and heroes must register or go underground.
  • A hero loses their powers, and has to keep going without them.
  • The sidekick discovers the mentor's dark secret.
  • A civilian journalist is close to exposing a hero's identity.
  • A team of heroes who can't stand each other.

Pitfalls

  • Power creep: new abilities showing up whenever the plot needs them.
  • The unbeatable hero: if they always win, nothing matters. See The Mary Sue Test.
  • All action, no life: the quiet scenes, eating takeaway in costume, explaining a black eye to their mum, make the fights matter.
  • Canon characters: if you play a famous hero, note your universe and version. See How to Roleplay a Canon Character.

For battles, see Roleplay Guide to Fighting. Superhero teams make great group roleplays; see Group Roleplay.