To write a convincing immortal character, decide the rules of their immortality, then think through what centuries of living do to a person: their memory, their grief, their habits, and how they relate to people who will die.
Vampires, elves, gods, cursed sailors, ancient witches and people who simply stopped ageing are roleplay favourites. The best ones feel old, not just young-looking with a long backstory.
Set the rules
- What kind of immortal? Ageless but killable, like many elves and vampires? Unable to die at all? Reborn each time they die?
- How did it happen? Born that way, a curse, a bargain, an experiment, a gift?
- What can still hurt them? Injury, pain, specific weapons, loneliness.
- Can it end? Is there a way to become mortal, or to die? Do they want one?
- Are there others? A whole people, a few scattered survivors, or only them?
Agree on the rules with your partner before they matter in a fight. See Power Balance in RP.
What a long life does to a person
Memory
Nobody remembers five hundred years clearly. Immortals might mix up decades, forget faces, keep diaries to hold on, or remember one day in 1740 more vividly than last week.
Grief
Everyone they love dies. Some immortals stop letting people in. Others love fiercely anyway, knowing the cost. Others keep a ritual for each person they've lost. How your character handles grief is the heart of who they are.
Habits and anachronisms
Old habits leak through: slang from three centuries ago, handwriting nobody can read any more, distrust of banks, an instinct to bow, a strong opinion about the invention of the fork. Pick a few and use them.
Boredom and meaning
What keeps them going? A mission, curiosity, a promise, a feud, simple stubbornness? An immortal with nothing to live for is a tragedy waiting to happen.
Change, or not
Some immortals adapt to every era. Others stopped somewhere and never caught up. Both are interesting: the vampire who loves smartphones and the elf still writing letters with a quill.
Living among mortals
- Hiding: new names, forged papers, moving every decade before anyone notices they haven't aged.
- Money: old investments, hidden treasure, or genuine poverty.
- Love: romances with mortals have a built-in ending. That's exactly what makes them powerful.
- Watching history: they were there for things others only read about, and they may remember them very differently.
A short example
Elias still reached for his sword belt whenever someone knocked after dark. It had been two hundred years since he'd worn one. He opened the door with his hand flat against his hip, felt the empty air there, and smiled at the delivery driver as if nothing had happened.
One habit, one detail, and readers know he's old, he's been in danger, and he's good at hiding it.
Common mistakes
- Knows everything: living long doesn't mean learning everything. Give them blind spots.
- Met every famous person: one or two encounters are fun; a whole list of famous friends strains belief.
- Feels like a twenty-year-old: if their voice and choices could belong to a young mortal, think about what centuries would change.
- Can't be hurt in any way: without stakes, scenes go flat. If they can't die, threaten what they love.
For specific creatures, see Writing Non-Human Characters and Greek Mythology RP 101. Centuries of history make flashback threads easy; see Time Skips, Flashbacks, and Nonlinear Threads and Backstory Prompts.